You also need to include any tokens or emblems you may need.Īnother issue with Tabletop Simulator is its price. You’ll have to use other websites like Frogtown to put your decks together and import them into Tabletop Simulator. The first issue is that this app isn’t dedicated to Magic. I think Tabletop Simulator is the worst option for playing Commander online. It’s great for miniature war games, for instance, since you just have to pay $20 to have access to tons of minis compared to paying $60 a box. Tabletop Simulator is an excellent program for playing certain games online. Don’t be discouraged from checking out a lower-ranked program if it fits what you’re looking for in an online experience. You don't want to waste a bunch of time downloading one and building decks on it just to have to switch to a different program later.

It's good to know your options so you can choose the platform that works for what you want out of it. I’ve taken the time to rank each of them and look at their pros and cons. There are also free options for players looking to test out decks without having to buy cards. There's an option for everyone, whether you're looking to play with your physical cards or just simulate a game with digital ones.

There are luckily a few other options to play Commander online for those who seek it. Unfortunately, four years into MTG Arena's existence and there aren’t any signs of Commander coming to the platform.

The online format is a great space for testing out decks without having to build them physically, and it’s more convenient when you don't have time to go to your LGS or meet up with friends. Commander's Insight | Illustration by Mike JordanaĬommander is one of Magic's most popular formats, so it only makes sense that players would want a way to play online.

How to play magic online for free